Best lakes around Bay Shore are primarily found within parks and preserves, offering freshwater bodies and access to larger bays. Bay Shore, a hamlet on Long Island's South Shore, is known for its connection to the Great South Bay. While expansive inland lakes are not a dominant feature, areas like Southards Pond provide significant freshwater recreation. The region offers a mix of natural ponds, river-fed preserves, and scenic lake outlets for visitors.
Last updated: June 28, 2026
Highlight • Historical Site
Tip by
Highlight • Viewpoint
Tip by
Sign up now to discover places like this
Get recommendations on the best single tracks, peaks, & plenty of other exciting outdoor places.
Sign up for free
Highlight • Lake
Tip by
Highlight • Forest
Tip by
Highlight • Lake
Tip by
Start today with a free account
Your next adventure awaits.
Login or Signup
From this spot you get a nice view of a small waterfall flowing out of Belmont Lake into Carl's River. This is a pleasant spot to pause as you ride around Belmont Lake State Park and the surrounding area.
0
0
Connetquot River State Park Preserve is a 3,473-acre refuge of sandy pine barrens, wetlands, ponds, and woodlands. Visitors can find over 200 bird species and 300 plant species, along with other mammals, reptiles, amphibians, butterflies, and moths that once lived all over Long Island. This area was created as New York's first "State Park Preserve," and remains a protected area open to the public today.
0
0
The park boasts over 8 miles of multi-use trails, catering to both casual riders and those seeking a challenge. Choose from scenic, flat paths around Stump Pond, moderate rolling hills through wooded areas, or even a dedicated BMX track for adrenaline-pumping thrills.
0
0
Argyle Lake, situated in Belmont Lake State Park, boasts a serene 0.8-mile loop. Meandering through wooded landscapes with occasional open vistas and glimpses of the lake, this trail offers a tranquil escape.
0
0
Southards Pond is the main attraction with Southards Pond Park. The main trail basically walks up to the shore of the water on the west side of the reservoir and offers an immersion into nature without having to leave the city. This spot, on the south side of the pond, crosses the Carlls River on a bridge and looks out over the water.
0
0
Southards Pond offers beautiful views of the pond, streams, and wildlife. You can enjoy the tranquility of nature while getting some exercise. The trail is mostly flat and well-marked, so you don’t have to worry about getting lost or climbing steep hills. The best times to visit this trail are April through September, when the weather is pleasant and the foliage is lush. Dogs are welcome, but must be on a leash. Whether you are a beginner or a seasoned runner, you will find this trail to be a rewarding and relaxing way to explore the park.
0
0
The area where Belmont Lake funnels back into the Carlls River at the southern end of the reservoir is a popular viewing spot of the water. There is a bridge crossing the creek with a head-on view of the small cascade formed by the lake flowing into the tight waterway.
0
0
While Bay Shore is primarily known for its access to the Great South Bay, several freshwater bodies offer scenic beauty and recreation. Popular spots include Southards Pond, known for its tranquil views and wildlife, and the Belmont Lake outlet, which features a picturesque waterfall. Argyle Lake in Belmont Lake State Park also offers a serene loop trail.
Yes, several locations are great for families. Southards Pond features mostly flat, well-marked trails suitable for all ages. Connetquot River State Park Preserve is a vast natural refuge with diverse wildlife and plant species, offering educational opportunities. Additionally, Blydenburgh County Park and Argyle Lake are also considered family-friendly.
You'll find a variety of trails. Southards Pond offers mostly flat and well-marked trails, ideal for easy walks. Argyle Lake has a tranquil 0.8-mile loop through wooded landscapes. For more extensive options, Blydenburgh County Park boasts over 8 miles of multi-use trails, ranging from scenic flat paths to moderate rolling hills. You can explore more options in the Easy hikes around Bay Shore guide.
The best time to visit is typically from April through September. During these months, the weather is pleasant, and the foliage is lush, making for ideal conditions for walking, exercising, and enjoying the natural beauty, especially at places like Southards Pond.
Yes, the Main House at Connetquot River State Park Preserve is a significant historical site and a nearly 3,500-acre natural refuge. It features sandy pine barrens, wetlands, ponds, and woodlands along the pristine Connetquot River, home to over 200 bird and 300 plant species. Blydenburgh County Park also includes a historic mill district.
Yes, dogs are welcome at some locations, provided they are kept on a leash. For example, Southards Pond explicitly states that dogs are welcome on a leash, offering a great spot for a walk with your canine companion.
The natural areas around Bay Shore's lakes are rich in wildlife. At Southards Pond, you can observe various pond and stream wildlife. Connetquot River State Park Preserve is particularly notable, providing opportunities to see over 200 bird species and 300 plant species, along with various mammals, reptiles, amphibians, butterflies, and moths.
Absolutely. Many of the trails are suitable for running, and some parks offer cycling paths. For instance, Blydenburgh County Park has over 8 miles of multi-use trails, including options for riders. You can find detailed running routes in the Running Trails around Bay Shore guide and cycling routes in the Road Cycling Routes around Bay Shore guide.
The terrain varies, but many trails are accessible. Southards Pond is known for its mostly flat and well-marked paths, making it an easy option. Connetquot River State Park Preserve features sandy pine barrens, wetlands, and woodlands. Blydenburgh County Park offers a mix of scenic, flat paths and moderate rolling hills.
Visitors appreciate the tranquility and immersion in nature that these spots offer without having to travel far. The beautiful views of ponds, streams, and wildlife, along with well-maintained trails for walking and exercise, are frequently highlighted. The opportunity to explore diverse ecosystems and historical sites also adds to the appeal.
Yes, there are several picturesque viewpoints. The View of the waterfall at the Belmont Lake outlet is a popular spot to see Belmont Lake funneling into the Carlls River. Southards Pond offers beautiful views of the pond and surrounding streams. Argyle Lake also provides occasional open vistas of the lake during its loop trail.


Still not found your perfect lake around Bay Shore? Check out the guides of these regions to see even more beautiful places.