Top 8 Lakes around Shelter Island
Lakes around Shelter Island are characterized by freshwater ponds nestled between the North and South Forks of Long Island. The island's landscape features diverse ecosystems, including woodlands, tidal creeks, and natural preserves. These water bodies are integral to the island's aquifer system and provide serene settings for various outdoor activities. Shelter Island offers a natural environment for those seeking to explore its unique aquatic features.
Best lakes around Shelter Island
- The most popular lakes is Mashomack Preserve, a forest…
Last updated: June 28, 2026
Mashomack Preserve
Highlight • Forest
Tip by
Elizabeth A. Morton National Wildlife Refuge
Highlight • Natural
While open for visitors, the refuge …
Tip by
Sign up now to discover places like this
Get recommendations on the best single tracks, peaks, & plenty of other exciting outdoor places.
Sign up for free
Rocky Beach on Northwest Harbor
Highlight • Beach
Tip by
Inlet Pond County Park
Highlight • Lake
Tip by
Nicoll's Creen
Highlight • Lake
Tip by
Start today with a free account
Your next adventure awaits.
Login or Signup
Tips from the Community
Nicoll's Creen is a marshy bay, part of Mashomack Preserve. This area is great for birdwatching and a scenic spot for a break.
0
0
The 187-acre Elizabeth A. Morton National Wildlife Refuge on Long Island's north shore protects the Jessup's Neck peninsula, separating Little Peconic and Noyack Bays. While open for visitors, the refuge emphasizes protecting endangered species like piping plovers by prohibiting feeding wildlife, which can attract predators. Bird watching is excellent, especially for waterfowl in winter and songbirds in spring. To minimize disturbances, no pets are allowed, and part of the beach is closed April-August for nesting birds.
0
0
As you journey through Grace Estate Preserve, you'll discover a nice little rocky beach on the shore of the northwest harbor, this is an excellent isolated spot to relax in nature.
0
0
Be enchanted by the vibrant flutter of butterflies in the dedicated butterfly garden. This colorful haven is a delight for families and nature enthusiasts alike.
0
0
Nestled on Shelter Island, Mashomack Preserve is a 2,039-acre natural wonderland. It features diverse ecosystems from woodlands to tidal creeks, offering picturesque trails for hikers. Rich in biodiversity, it's a haven for birdwatchers and nature enthusiasts, showcasing the beauty of Long Island's wildlife.
1
0
Frequently Asked Questions
What kind of natural features can I expect to see around Shelter Island's ponds?
Shelter Island's ponds are integral to its diverse ecosystems, featuring woodlands, tidal creeks, and natural preserves. You can explore areas like Mashomack Preserve, which boasts diverse habitats from forests to tidal creeks, or the marshy bays of Nicoll's Creen. The island's freshwater ponds are also crucial to its aquifer system.
Are there family-friendly activities or trails near the ponds on Shelter Island?
Yes, several spots are great for families. Inlet Pond County Park is family-friendly and features a dedicated butterfly garden. Fresh Pond is also popular for swimming, kayaking, and paddle-boarding. Many trails, like those in Mashomack Preserve, are suitable for family walks.
Where can I go birdwatching around Shelter Island's ponds?
Shelter Island offers excellent birdwatching opportunities. Elizabeth A. Morton National Wildlife Refuge is a prime location, especially for waterfowl in winter and songbirds in spring. Fresh Pond is known for egrets at sunset, and Nicoll's Creen, a marshy bay, is also a great spot for bird enthusiasts.
Are there any dog-friendly areas near the lakes on Shelter Island?
Yes, Inlet Pond County Park is noted as a dog-friendly location where you can enjoy the natural surroundings with your pet.
What are some good spots for swimming or water activities on Shelter Island?
Fresh Pond is a popular spot for swimming, kayaking, and paddle-boarding. Inlet Pond County Park is also listed as a swim spot, offering another option for enjoying the water.
What kind of hiking trails are available near Shelter Island's ponds?
You'll find a variety of trails, from easy walks to more moderate paths. For example, the Mashomack Red Trail is an easy hike within the preserve. Dickerson Park Pond also features a loop trail for peaceful walks. You can find more options for easy hikes around Shelter Island.
Can I go cycling near the ponds on Shelter Island?
Yes, Shelter Island offers various cycling routes. You can explore options like the Shelter Island Heights – Dickerson Creek loop, which is a moderate cycling route. For more choices, check out the road cycling routes around Shelter Island or general cycling routes around Shelter Island.
What is the best time to visit the lakes and ponds on Shelter Island?
The best time to visit depends on your interests. Spring is excellent for observing songbirds at places like Elizabeth A. Morton National Wildlife Refuge, while winter is ideal for waterfowl. August is a good time to see swamp mallows in bloom around Dickerson Park Pond. Generally, warmer months are best for water activities like swimming and kayaking.
Are there any historical sites or unique features near the ponds?
Ice Pond, a 9-acre park, has a unique historical element with the ruined and abandoned smokestack of a former incinerator, giving it an 'old world' quality. Historically, it was used for ice harvesting and incinerating resort waste.
Are there any quiet spots for relaxation near the water?
Yes, Rocky Beach on Northwest Harbor is described as an excellent isolated spot to relax in nature. Dickerson Park Pond also offers a peaceful setting for a quiet walk.
What kind of fish can be found in Fresh Pond?
Fresh Pond is a popular spot for fishing, with species such as Largemouth Bass, Smallmouth Bass, Bluegill, Pumpkinseed, and Carp.
What is the significance of Fresh Pond to Shelter Island?
Fresh Pond is highly significant as it is the largest exposed portion of Shelter Island's groundwater and serves as the sole source of drinking water for the island. It's also undergoing a long-term restoration project to improve its health and water quality.
Most popular attractions around Shelter Island
Get inspired with the komoot mobile app
Explore more
Still not found your perfect lake around Shelter Island? Check out the guides of these regions to see even more beautiful places.
