Best lakes around Sag Harbor are characterized by a diverse array of natural water bodies, ranging from tidal saltwater ponds to freshwater lakes and significant estuarine systems. This region, situated on Long Island, features picturesque coves and coastal plain ponds that are remnants of melting glaciers. The area offers a blend of ecological significance and recreational opportunities, making it a notable destination for nature exploration. Its unique geography supports varied ecosystems and wildlife, contributing to its natural appeal.
Last updated: June 27, 2026
Highlight • Forest
Tip by
Highlight • Natural
Tip by
Sign up now to discover places like this
Get recommendations on the best single tracks, peaks, & plenty of other exciting outdoor places.
Sign up for free
Highlight • Beach
Tip by
Highlight • Lake
Tip by
Start today with a free account
Your next adventure awaits.
Login or Signup
Nicoll's Creen is a marshy bay, part of Mashomack Preserve. This area is great for birdwatching and a scenic spot for a break.
0
0
The 187-acre Elizabeth A. Morton National Wildlife Refuge on Long Island's north shore protects the Jessup's Neck peninsula, separating Little Peconic and Noyack Bays. While open for visitors, the refuge emphasizes protecting endangered species like piping plovers by prohibiting feeding wildlife, which can attract predators. Bird watching is excellent, especially for waterfowl in winter and songbirds in spring. To minimize disturbances, no pets are allowed, and part of the beach is closed April-August for nesting birds.
0
0
As you journey through Grace Estate Preserve, you'll discover a nice little rocky beach on the shore of the northwest harbor, this is an excellent isolated spot to relax in nature.
0
0
Nestled on Shelter Island, Mashomack Preserve is a 2,039-acre natural wonderland. It features diverse ecosystems from woodlands to tidal creeks, offering picturesque trails for hikers. Rich in biodiversity, it's a haven for birdwatchers and nature enthusiasts, showcasing the beauty of Long Island's wildlife.
1
0
Yes, several ponds and coves are suitable for families. Mashomack Preserve offers picturesque trails that are great for all ages. Otter Pond, located near the village, is excellent for birdwatching, especially in early summer when ducklings and goslings are visible. Round Pond is also easily accessible and offers opportunities for snorkeling and ice-skating in winter, making it a versatile family spot.
The region is excellent for birdwatching. Otter Pond is known for its diverse waterfowl population, including ducks, swans, and geese. Elizabeth A. Morton National Wildlife Refuge is another prime location, especially for waterfowl in winter and songbirds in spring. Additionally, Nicoll's Creen, a marshy bay within Mashomack Preserve, is a scenic spot for observing birds.
Many areas offer trails with scenic water views. The Long Pond Greenbelt, which includes Long Pond and Crooked Pond, features numerous trails like Sprig Tree Path and Widow Gavitts, providing immersive experiences in nature. Mashomack Preserve also has diverse ecosystems, from woodlands to tidal creeks, with trails offering beautiful vistas.
The lakes and ponds around Sag Harbor are rich in wildlife. Otter Pond is home to diverse waterfowl. Round Pond hosts dragonflies, muskrats, and various birds like buffleheads and ospreys. The Long Pond Greenbelt, encompassing Long Pond and Crooked Pond, is particularly noted for its wealth of over 30 rare species of plants and animals. Sag Harbor Cove is a productive area for shellfish, marine finfish, and serves as a wintering ground for waterfowl.
Yes, several locations are suitable for paddle sports. Long Pond has a dirt boat launch off Widow Gavitts trail, perfect for kayaking or canoeing. Sagaponack Pond, also known as Sagg Pond, can be explored by shallow-draft paddle craft from an entry point near the bridge on Bridge Lane. Little Fresh Pond also mentions kayaking and paddle boating as popular activities.
The best time to visit depends on your interests. Early summer is ideal for seeing ducklings and goslings at Otter Pond. Autumn offers stunning foliage around Trout Pond, making it perfect for hikers. Spring and winter provide excellent birdwatching opportunities at Elizabeth A. Morton National Wildlife Refuge, with winter also popular for ice-skating at Round Pond.
For a tranquil experience, Crooked Pond is considered the 'Queen of the Greenbelt's coastal plain ponds' due to its pristine condition and undeveloped shoreline. It offers a peaceful retreat for hikers. Trout Pond also provides a serene natural environment, ideal for those seeking a quiet escape for hiking and angling.
Beyond enjoying the lakes themselves, the area offers various outdoor activities. You can find excellent running trails, including the Long Pond Greenbelt Trail, by exploring the Running Trails around Sag Harbor guide. For cycling enthusiasts, routes like the Shelter Island Heights loop are available in the Cycling around Sag Harbor guide, and road cycling options can be found in the Road Cycling Routes around Sag Harbor guide.
Swimming is possible in some areas. Round Pond is known for its clear, groundwater-fed waters suitable for snorkeling and swimming. Little Fresh Pond is also mentioned as suitable for swimming. However, swimming is discouraged in Trout Pond due to varying water depths and potentially dangerous bottom conditions.
Sag Harbor Cove, encompassing Outer, Inner, and Upper Sag Harbor Coves, is a vital estuarine system central to the village's maritime character. It's a highly productive area for shellfish and marine finfish, an important wintering ground for waterfowl, and supports commercial and recreational fishing and boating. It's integral to the local ecosystem and the village's historical identity as a working port.
Yes, Crooked Pond, part of the Long Pond Greenbelt, features a unique Truman Capote memorial stone located in a small clearing at its edge, offering a connection to local literary history. Additionally, Otter Pond is situated at the entrance to the historic whaling village of Sag Harbor, providing easy access to the village's rich history.


Still not found your perfect lake around Sag Harbor? Check out the guides of these regions to see even more beautiful places.