4.3
(11)
112
hikers
22
hikes
Hikes around West Islip feature a landscape of coastal paths, lakeside trails, and unique woodland preserves. Situated on the South Shore of Long Island, the region is characterized by its generally flat terrain, with routes passing through state parks, nature preserves, and along the Great South Bay. The area's trails navigate through a mix of maritime forests, sandy beaches, and rare habitats like pine-scrub oak barrens.
Last updated: May 12, 2026
4.0
(4)
7
hikers
7.69km
01:57
10m
10m
Easy hike. Great for any fitness level. Easily-accessible paths. Suitable for all skill levels.
1
hikers
5.63km
01:25
10m
10m
Easy hike. Great for any fitness level. Easily-accessible paths. Suitable for all skill levels.

Sign up for free
1
hikers
2.36km
00:36
0m
0m
Easy hike. Great for any fitness level. Easily-accessible paths. Suitable for all skill levels.
1.52km
00:23
0m
0m
Easy hike. Great for any fitness level. Easily-accessible paths. Suitable for all skill levels.
1.37km
00:21
0m
0m
Easy hike. Great for any fitness level. Easily-accessible paths. Suitable for all skill levels.
Get access to more routes and recommendations from other explorers.
Sign up for free
Already have an account?
Our route recommendations are based on thousands of hikes, rides, and runs completed by other people on komoot.
Start today with a free account
Your next adventure awaits.
Login or Signup
Popular around West Islip
From this spot you get a nice view of a small waterfall flowing out of Belmont Lake into Carl's River. This is a pleasant spot to pause as you ride around Belmont Lake State Park and the surrounding area.
0
0
Rising majestically along the shores of Fire Island, the iconic lighthouse stands as a testament to maritime history. In its prime, it guided countless transatlantic ships safely into New York Harbor, serving as the first welcoming sight for European immigrants seeking a new life in America. The current tower, built in the 19th century, replaced an earlier, inadequate structure, ensuring mariners received a reliable beacon through the ever-shifting sands. Today, this lighthouse remains a beloved landmark, its presence evoking memories of the past while continuing to symbolize hope and new beginnings.
0
0
Belmont Lake State Park and the path running through it makes a perfect spot to cycle through off of the road and enjoy the green scenery. With the Carlis River running through it, there is plenty to see along the way.
0
0
Southards Pond Park is a popular spot for easy hiking in Babylon, New York. There is a dirt hiking loop that circles the Southards Pond (the centerpiece of the park) and a couple other paths that follow the Carlls River south.
0
0
This was a crucial landmark in New York for transatlantic ships arriving in the area. You have the opportunity to enter the lighthouse and take a 182-step tour of the tower, adding a bit of extra exercise to your trip. It's important to check for hours of operation, as they may vary throughout the year. You can find more information on their website: https://www.fireislandlighthouse.com/planyourvisit
0
0
If you are looking for a scenic and relaxing trail run, you might want to check out Southards Pond Park in Babylon, New York. This park features a 1.4-mile loop trail that circles around a large pond, where you can enjoy the views of the water and the wildlife. The trail is mostly flat and easy, with some dirt footpaths and wooden bridges. You can access the trail from many points around the pond, but the south shoreline offers the easiest access. The park is open from dawn to dusk. Southards Pond Park is a great place to enjoy nature and get some fresh air while running.
0
0
The area where Belmont Lake funnels back into the Carlls River at the southern end of the reservoir is a popular viewing spot of the water. There is a bridge crossing the creek with a head-on view of the small cascade formed by the lake flowing into the tight waterway.
0
0
Belmont Lake is fed by the Carlls River and features a few tiny islands in the middle of the reservoir. There are docks, benches, picnic tables, and a small pier on the east side of the water. The dam on the south side of the lake is another popular hiking destination.
0
0
Yes, many local parks welcome dogs on leashes. Gardiner County Park in Bay Shore is a particular favorite among dog owners, offering a mix of woodland and coastal trails. Always check the specific park's regulations before you go, as some preserves may have restrictions to protect wildlife.
The area is great for family outings. Belmont Lake State Park offers a classic experience with a gravel path around the lake that's perfect for a leisurely stroll. For a unique walk, consider the View of Long Island Beach – Fire Island Lighthouse loop from Fair Harbor, which is a short, flat walk with the reward of seeing the iconic lighthouse.
Yes, you can find paved trails in the region. Edgewood Oak Brush Plains Preserve has a network that includes paved multi-use paths, making it accessible. Heckscher State Park also features some paved trails that wind through woodlands and offer views of the Great South Bay.
For expansive water views, Heckscher State Park is an excellent choice, with trails along the Great South Bay. For a different kind of scenery, the Lighthouse Beach to Ocean Promenade — Robert Moses State Park route provides beautiful coastal vistas and a chance to see the Fire Island Lighthouse up close.
Long Island is known for its relatively flat terrain, so you won't find any mountains. However, for a bit of elevation, you can head to the Walt Whitman Trail in West Hills County Park. This trail takes you to Jayne's Hill, the highest point on Long Island, offering some nice views of the surrounding area.
The trails in Belmont Lake State Park are generally well-maintained and suitable for all skill levels. The main feature is a gravel path circling the lake, which is mostly flat. Other trails follow the Carll's River through wetlands and woodlands, offering a pleasant and accessible hiking experience.
The popular Edgewood Oak Brush Plains Preserve loop is approximately 3.1 miles (5.0 km) long. It's an easy walk that typically takes about an hour and fifteen minutes to complete, leading you through the preserve's unique pine barrens habitat.
Yes, for a longer outing, the Argyle Lake to Belmont Lake — Belmont Lake State Park trail is a great option. It's a 7.7-mile (12.3 km) route that connects two parks by following the Carll's River. Additionally, the 31-mile Long Island Greenbelt Trail begins in Heckscher State Park, offering a more extensive challenge for serious hikers.
The trails around West Islip are highly rated by the komoot community, with an average score of 4.4 stars. Hikers often praise the variety of scenery, from the serene lakeside paths at Belmont Lake to the unique coastal barrens at Edgewood Preserve and the beautiful bay views at Heckscher State Park.
There are over 15 curated hiking routes to explore around West Islip. These range from short, easy loops perfect for a quick walk to more moderate, longer trails connecting different parks and preserves.
The diverse habitats support a variety of wildlife. Heckscher State Park is a popular spot for birdwatching, with over 280 species recorded, and you might also see white-tailed deer. Belmont Lake's wetlands attract waterfowl like herons and ospreys, while Edgewood Oak Brush Plains Preserve is home to species adapted to its rare habitat, such as the coastal barrens buckmoth.
Most of the major state parks, such as Belmont Lake State Park, Heckscher State Park, and Robert Moses State Park, have large, designated parking areas. However, they can get busy, especially on weekends and during the summer. A vehicle use fee is often required for entry during peak season.


Browse the best Hikes in other regions.